Who is the Best Sales Coach? Manager vs Peer vs Outsourced

Like it? Share it!Share on LinkedInShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookEmail this to someone

I recently wrote a post on LinkedIn about why sales managers don’t coach. In the comments to that post, a few people suggested that front line sales managers shouldn’t be coaching at all. Instead, they said, coaching should be done by peers (“who wants to be criticized by their boss”) or outsourced (“the skills don’t exist in the organization”).

So what makes sense to you? I’m really asking here!

Here are some of my thoughts:

(All of) What the Front Line Sales Manager Should Be Doing

In an opinion influenced by the great Dave Kurlan, I’ve always believed that a front line sales manager should focus time with their reps on five key things:

  1. Coaching
  2. Mentoring
  3. Motivating
  4. Accountability
  5. Recruiting (and un-recruiting…)

As I see it, these are not separate functions, rather – they are integrated, and a front line sales manager should be responsible for all of it:

Bring someone in, set the playing field, set expectations, check in regularly, and work to help them improve as they go….

It makes a lot of sense that coaching is a big part of this, and that this coaching is done by the person who is doing the other things as well.

For me, it’s hard to imagine that these highly integrated sales management responsibilities would be done by anyone but the front line sales manager.

In other words, while a peer or outsourced coach might coach, mentor, and motivate – you can’t really imagine them holding reps accountable or recruiting. All of it – together – makes the picture complete.

Why is the manager the manager?

Those who suggest that a peer or an outsourced coach is a better option have some valid points, but it begs the question:

If the manager isn’t coaching, why have them as a manager?

If the manager was promoted from rep – which is almost always the case – then presumably they are a strong seller. How does it make sense to promote a strong seller, have them keep their big quota, add administrative tasks but NOT give them room to share their winning ways with the team?

Normally, the push back from the peer & outsourced fans is that the manager is too busy with their new manager duties and may not be good coaches anyways, so they don’t have time or the talent / skills to coach.

How does that make sense – I’m really asking here?

  • If you want a great rep to sell, why promote them to manager and saddle them with non-sales work?
  • If you have a great rep that should be coaching as a peer, why promote them to manager and keep them from doing that?
  • And if you are thinking about bringing someone in from the outside, why is that better than a person who is doing a great job from the inside? Wouldn’t it be better to teach that person how to coach effectively and to set them up for success in either peer or manager coaching?

So – I’m sure you can see that I am pretty firmly in the “manager should be the coach” camp, but please – push back – enlighten me – is this the right approach and if not, what is and why?

****************************************************

Authors note (AKA shameless plugs)

So, this 7-step sales process and associated topics…. Yup, I write about that a lot. I’ve been working with it since I developed it about 25 years ago – in my own diverse work experiences, with my teams when I had them, and with clients ever since.

If you would like to develop you own personalized and customized, highly effective and efficient B2B selling system, here are some further steps you can take:

The Salesman’s Guide to Dating is a free or very cheap (depending on Amazon) Kindle book that walks you through the sales process using the familiar analogy of dating. It’s a good, fun and quick way to get your mind around the whole process and how the pieces fit together.

Building Your Sales Process (BYSP) is a free and very thorough exploration of the same 7-step process that will walk you through the development of your own customized, personal B2B selling system. When you are done, you will know exactly what to do to get new business.

The Momentum Selling System® is an inexpensive but very robust online sales training course that is similar to BYSP, but goes deeper into the concepts behind each of the steps, and also helps you develop a plan not only for the 7-step process but also addresses mindset, repeat business and client base management.

If none of that sounds right, I do personal coaching and offer a free 30-minute intake session so that we can both learn if it makes sense to work together 1-on-1. If this sounds interesting, click over to the coaching page on this site and sign up for the free session.

Here’s to your success!

-David

Like it? Share it!Share on LinkedInShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookEmail this to someone